Build Your Own

Box of 12 – Build A Box of Cookies

Create your perfect dozen with our Build-a-Box of 12 Cookies! Choose up to four flavors from our selection of 20 delicious cookies, including seasonal favorites. Perfect for gifting or treating yourself, this custom cookie box lets you mix and match flavors for the ultimate sweet experience. We bake and ship same day for perfect freshness.  

Box of 18 – Build A Box of Cookies

Why settle for one flavor when you can have many? Our Build-a-Box of 18 Cookies lets you mix and match up to four flavors from our signature cookie collection. Share with family, send as a gift, or keep them all to yourself—we won’t tell!  We bake and ship same day for perfect freshness.  

Tray of 24 – Custom Cookie Tray

Our Custom Cookie Tray of 24 is perfect for parties, office events, or sweet family gatherings. Choose up to four cookie flavors from our ever-changing lineup of up to 20 delicious varieties including seasonal favorites. A beautiful presentation and unbeatable flavor make this tray the ultimate crowd-pleaser.  We bake and ship same day for perfect freshness.  

Tray of 36 – Custom Cookie Tray

Bring big smiles to any event with our Custom Cookie Tray of 36. Mix and match up to four flavors from our best-selling and seasonal cookies for a tray that everyone will love. Perfect for celebrations, office meetings, or any time you want to impress with gourmet cookies.  We bake and ship same day for perfect freshness.  

Make every celebration extra special with our beautifully arranged tray of 50 gourmet cookies. Each cookie is homemade with premium ingredients, baked and shipped the same day for maximum freshness.  

Customize your tray by choosing up to four cookie flavors from our wide selection,

Our delicious Colossal Cookies are sure to leave you satisfied. These 4 ounce cookies are baked to perfection and deliver BIG flavor!

Enjoy 6 of our extra large Chocolate Chip or Oatmeal Raisin cookies wrapped in our signature gold box - perfect for sharing with a group or gifting for a special event. 

Enjoy the best homemade cookies with No Gluten Added! Perfect for those with sensitivities and just as satisfying for everyone else. Featuring two irresistible flavors: Orange Oatmeal Cranberry combine tart cranberries, hearty oats, with citrus notes, and Chocolate Chip bursting with semi sweet chocolate chips in every bite. Thoughtfully crafted with whole grain oat flour and brown rice flour, this assortment offers a satisfying, indulgent treat without added gluten.

Each order arrives in a beautifully packaged gold gift box, available in 12 or 18 cookies. Cookies are 2 oz and approximately 3 inches in diameter.

Allergen Notice: These cookies are produced in a facility that also processes wheat and other gluten-containing products.

There’s nothing like the comforting taste of a perfectly baked oatmeal cookie. Our Oatmeal Assortment brings together three irresistible variations, each crafted to satisfy every kind of sweet craving.

This assortment includes 6 Oatmeal Raisin, 6 Oatmeal Orange Cranberry, and 6 Vegan Dark Chocolate Oatmeal cookies—each baked fresh with premium ingredients for the perfect balance of flavor and texture.

Let’s eat cookies for a great cause!  Famous 4th Street Cookies has partnered with Ronald McDonald House for a special treat to honor volunteers and families. The Ronald McDonald House Cookie Box includes 6 Chocolate Chip, 6 Rainbow with M&Ms, and 6 White Chocolate Cranberry. This box includes a special message of thanks from Ronald McDonald House.  In addition, a donation of $25 will be sent to the Ronald McDonald House in honor of your recipient.  What a wonderful way to send a special treat and give back to our community supporting the programs of the the Ronald McDonald House!

Enjoy Blakelyn's S'mores Cookie while supporting Make-A-Wish! Blakelyn's Cookie was the winner of our Kids Baking Competition. Make-A-Wish® creates life-changing wishes for children with critical illnesses. We seek to bring every eligible child's wish to life because a wish is an integral part of a child's treatment journey. Research shows children who have wishes granted can build the physical and emotional strength they need to fight their illness. The Make-A-Wish Box of Cookies includes: 

• 9 Chocolate Chip Cookies
  
• 9 S'mores Cookies (Created by Wish Kid and Kids Baking Competition Winner Blakelyn)
  

Proceeds from this Make-A-Wish Box are donated to Make-A-Wish.